Bajan Tuh De Bone

Jock wrote:Actually there are people who challenge this definition. They have the organs but chromosomes say the opposite. So which are they?

I would think it is logical to go with the side that manifest itself in the reproductive organs.

Jock wrote:But your definition is for one purpose, theirs is for a different one.

My definition is for the same purpose...sports competition. If she has female reproductive organs and she's not allowed to compete with women because their tests say she is male, then will she be allowed to compete against men...or would there still be some controversy with that??

In that case he would have to compete with athletes of his sex.

Oh for sure people would still have issues.

Jock wrote:In that case he would have to compete with athletes of his sex.

Oh for sure people would still have issues.

As long as "she" got "female" reproductive organs I gine refer tuh she as "she"...regardless of what de IAAF say "she" is.

she get a mek-over boy. she hands still look big as wha doah. woman look like she cud slap a fella into next week

Hey Skule...those big hands wud gih she a bettah grip pun yuh willy.

I see mo feminine looking ladyboys in Bangkok

He look like 'e ready fuh de "queen o' de Bs" show.

Jock wrote:I see mo feminine looking ladyboys in Bangkok

You sound like you was tempted to touch.

Nuh temptation but unless sumting or sumbody tell yuh, yuh really cahn tell
Is possible dat sum dem women mite not have been women after all - yuh never know

Cast a diffrunt lite pon de name Bangkok

Gearbox wrote:Hey Skule...those big hands wud gih she a bettah grip pun yuh willy.

wid dem sorta hands she cud leff a fellla willyless

Gearbox wrote:You sound like you was tempted to touch.

No, I definitely gotta pass dey.

Jock wrote:Nuh temptation but unless sumting or sumbody tell yuh, yuh really cahn tell
Is possible dat sum dem women mite not have been women after all - yuh never know

Cast a diffrunt lite pon de name Bangkok

Yeah...I remember seeing a documentary on those Thai ladyboys. Some wud fool any man in trute.

ohhhhh shhhhhhhooooot! um is a he-she. I tell all wunnah dem hands too big. wunnah right bout the ladyboy thing fa true. wuhloss!!

Well cahn say dat I suhprise. Figure dat dis was a likely possibility.
If true, dis mean s/he is mo he dan she cause de she part is fuh show only while de he part doing all de wuk ie building muscles, lung capacity etc.
Wich is wuh de IAAF wud be concern bout cause um cahn be fair tuh de real, real women dat he wud competing against.
So we wait fuh de official position.

I gine wait fuh de official word. But I wud say dat if "it" ain got no womb or ovaries, then "it" cannot be a female. A hermaphrodite cannot be classified as either male or female...but just a hermaphrodite.

But yuh kin see why it ent such a simple matter as you & many others first thought, rite?
Not only is a question of fairness in competition but also legal issues - which might well been the IAAF main concern (fear :))

Jock wrote:But yuh kin see why it ent such a simple matter as you & many others first thought, rite?
Not only is a question of fairness in competition but also legal issues - which might well been the IAAF main concern (fear :))

Um is still a clear cut thing to me. If she had a womb and ovaries, and no penis or balls, then she would have to be female. And if he has a penis and balls, and no womb or ovaries, then he has to be a man. If there is a mixture of both sex organs, or parts are missing that should be there, then it has to be a hermaphrodite. Can't get more clear cut than that to me.

So if Caster is really a herma wud Caster have to compete in de Special Olympics in a category for hermaphrodites?

Wuh I say is dat de IAAF test is to determine wedduh Caster eligible to compete as a female, dah's all.

Special Olympics got nutten to do wid it & is quite possible dat de same tests mite be requested anyway since dey have male & female categories.

I tink s/he career done, cause de women 'in gine wanta compete wid eem, and she too slow fuh de men.

Wuh disgust me is dat s/he fadduh did know all de while dat s/he is a hermaphrodite, but questioning de entire word's speculation dat s/he 'in normal.